aren't they too young to grade their teacher

            It is a must that teachers are responsible to help students get the lesson. It means they have close relationship. Both of them have their own point of view for each. As we know teachers assess their mentee trough the report. American schools have a system that at the end of the year, they will do survey about each teacher. Having to write sentences usually deals with those students. But is it right for allowing students to do so? Let’s check it out !

As human being teachers absolutely will have such kind of mistakes on teaching and learning process. Unfortunately those who realize it is their students, unconsciously students will assess and judge them. That is the wrong way of judgement. Here the nature of teachers it self are the one who help students to understand the knowledge easily. From that statement we can take that teachers have something more compared to the students. Especially knowledge and experiences as they have born far earlier than students. That is why it’s like unsuitable way to judge somebody that have more experiences than them.

Regarding to their age, students are not compatible enough to give the fair assessment. We can say that they are fickle, even sometimes they will be careless towards it. They will not be able to make such kind of fair consideration on grading their teacher. Moreover, they will ignore the nature of teacher, for example some female students might grade the most handsome teacher more, and the boys might judge the most beautiful one. It proves that idea of judging is not about the quality of knowledge that the got, but it based on students’ mood instead.

Last but not least, allowing students to grade the teacher directly is nor the best way to evaluate the teacher. When teacher’s correcting student’s assignment or quiz, automatically they will know how far their students understand about the material that they gave. From its result, teacher can analyze whether they need to improve their method or not. Trough this way, there will be no side taht hurt, cause students can’t create good diction so that it will hurt their teacher.

Indeed students have right to do the judgement, but we need to think about the nature of teacher and students as well. That is why it will be bad if we allowed them to grade their teachers.